djop, I think the first snow on Mt. Washington will fall in September, with as much as 18" additional in October. I believe the mountain has had some snowfall at some time in all the 12 months. September snow is not that unusual.
Colonel, pick a date. Let's make the game up to 2 days before and 1 days after. So 10/7 (my guess above) wins for 10/5 and 10/8. That should help keep it interesting I think.